A desk with a calculator, legal documents, and a pen beside a Georgia state map.

Fee Guide | Duluth, Georgia

Is a 40% Lawyer Fee High? Questions to Ask Before You Sign

Plain answers on what a percentage fee covers, which costs come out first, and what to read in the agreement before you commit.

By Peter F. Jaraysi · Published November 13, 2026

You’re probably reading this because someone you love was hurt or killed, and a lawyer’s agreement now lists a 40% fee. Asking whether that’s fair is a reasonable step before you sign anything.

Is 40% high for lawyer fees? Not by itself. A percentage only means something once you know what it applies to, which costs come out first, and what the written agreement says.

Short Answer: Is 40% High for a Lawyer’s Fee?

A 40% fee is not high or low on its face. Whether it’s reasonable depends on the work involved, the agreement’s wording, and how case costs are handled.

Two agreements can both say 40% and leave a client with very different amounts. A fee can be calculated on the gross recovery, which is the total paid before anything is subtracted. It can also be calculated on the net recovery, which is what remains after case costs come out.

Calculating on the net leaves more money with the client, all else equal. The percentage looks the same on paper, but the math is not.

This page explains what shapes a percentage, which costs can sit on top of it, and what to ask. The goal is to help you read the agreement in front of you and compare it with those questions.

If a crash or a death in your family has you reviewing a fee agreement right now, our team can talk it through with you in a free, confidential first consultation. Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.

What a Contingency Fee Means

A contingency fee is a share of the money recovered for you, rather than an hourly bill. The percentage is set in a written agreement you sign with the firm.

You may still owe court costs and case expenses even though the fee itself is contingent. Read that part of the agreement as closely as the percentage.

A retainer works differently. It is an upfront payment for legal work, and its terms vary by agreement. For many injury clients, a contingency agreement means no upfront legal bill.

Read the fee percentage and the costs language together. They belong to the same agreement, and one changes what the other means.

Why Fee Percentages Vary From Case to Case

Fee percentages vary because the work varies. A claim that settles early through negotiation involves different work than a claim that must be filed as a lawsuit.

A lawsuit can bring discovery, where each side asks for records and sworn testimony. It can also bring depositions and trial preparation. Each step takes time, so the agreement should explain how the fee applies at each stage.

Liability can make the work heavier too. Georgia reduces damages by the injured person’s share of fault, and a plaintiff who is 50 percent or more responsible recovers no damages (O.C.G.A. § 51-12-33).

When several parties share blame, or when an insurer disputes who was at fault, investigation takes more effort. Cases with commercial defendants or unclear liability can take longer for the same reason.

Costs and Expenses That Can Sit on Top of the Fee

Case costs are separate from the fee, and they can reduce what reaches you. Costs are not the same as the percentage, so ask about them directly.

Common case expenses include filing fees, charges for medical and business records, witness fees, and deposition costs. The agreement should say which of these you pay, when you pay them, and whether they come out before or after the fee is figured.

Medical bills need attention too. Georgia treats necessary expenses from an injury as a legitimate part of the damages estimate (O.C.G.A. § 51-12-7).

Medicare can also be involved. Under federal rules, CMS has a right to recover its conditional payments from any entity that received a primary payment, including an attorney (42 C.F.R. § 411.24).

Close-up of a desk with a legal document, calculator, and pen, suggesting a discussion of attorney fees in Georgia.

Working Through the Arithmetic With an Illustration

The order of subtraction can change what you keep, even at the same percentage.

Here is a made-up example. It is an illustration only, not a prediction or a result. Assume a $20,000 recovery, $1,500 in case costs, and a $2,000 medical lien paid from the recovery.

  • 40% on the gross: The fee is $8,000. After costs, $10,500 remains. After the lien, $8,500 remains.
  • 40% on the net: Costs come out first, leaving $18,500. The fee is $7,400. After the lien, $9,100 remains.
  • 33% on the gross: The fee is $6,600. After costs, $11,900 remains. After the lien, $9,900 remains.

At the same 40% rate, the net method leaves $600 more than the gross method. Your agreement’s wording decides which method applies.

Actual figures depend on the agreement, the costs, and any liens in the case. Use this example only to see how the wording moves the numbers.

Questions to Ask Before You Sign a Fee Agreement

Start with one question: is the percentage applied to the gross recovery or the net recovery? Ask for the answer in writing.

Then ask these questions:

  • Which case costs do I pay, and when?
  • If the case does not produce a recovery, do I owe costs?
  • How are medical bills and liens paid from any recovery?
  • How does the fee change if the case settles early compared with going to trial?
  • Can someone explain each line of this agreement in plain terms?

Keep a signed copy. Write down the answers you receive, with the date you received them.

Not sure what your next step is?

Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.

Fees in Wrongful Death and Serious Injury Matters

In a Georgia wrongful death case, state law decides who may recover and how the money is shared. Those rules shape the fee conversation.

A surviving spouse, or if there is no surviving spouse, a child or children, may recover the full value of the decedent’s life, as shown by the evidence (O.C.G.A. § 51-4-2). The surviving spouse receives no less than one-third of that recovery. No recovery under that subsection is subject to the decedent’s debts or the estate’s debts.

When death results from a crime or from criminal or other negligence, the personal representative may recover funeral, medical, and other necessary expenses resulting from the injury and death (O.C.G.A. § 51-4-5).

Families often face unfamiliar paperwork at the same time as the loss itself. Serious injuries can bring large medical bills, so the cost and lien questions above matter even more.

Georgia’s general deadline for injury lawsuits is two years after the right of action accrues (O.C.G.A. § 9-3-33). Learning your fee options early gives you more time to think them through. For background, see our Georgia wrongful death guide and truck accident wrongful death page.

Talk Through Your Situation With Our Team

If you’re reviewing a fee agreement while grieving or recovering, or while helping a family member through a loss or injury they didn’t choose, you don’t have to sort out the paperwork alone.

Our team at Slam Dunk Attorney can talk through the percentage, the costs language, and the questions above with you. The first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation to continue. Contact our team to start that conversation.

This page is general information, not legal advice. Slam Dunk Attorney is based in Duluth, Georgia, and serves metro Atlanta and clients across Georgia. Responsible lawyer for this page: Peter F. Jaraysi. Contact: slamdunkattorney.com/contact-us.

Attorney advertising. The information on this page is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice; reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship with Slam Dunk Attorney. Peter F. Jaraysi is the lawyer responsible for this content. Slam Dunk Attorney, 2250 Satellite Blvd, Ste. 120, Duluth, GA 30097, 404-951-3513.

Why Talk With Our Team Before You Decide

A free first consultation

Our initial consultation is free, confidential, and comes with no obligation to continue.

We walk through the agreement

We can explain each line of a fee agreement in plain language so you know what you are signing.

Support for families

Our team understands that a crash, injury, or loss affects the whole family, and we treat every question with care.

Based in Duluth, Georgia

We represent people across metro Atlanta and Georgia in car, truck, motorcycle, rideshare, and other injury matters.

Read the Whole Agreement First

Do not sign a fee agreement until you understand what the percentage is applied to, which costs are deducted first, and whether you may still owe court costs and case expenses. Ask for an explanation in writing if anything is unclear.

Four Questions to Ask About Any Fee

What is the percentage applied to?

Find out whether the percentage is taken from the gross amount or from the amount left after certain costs are paid.

What if there is no recovery?

Ask in writing what you would owe if the case does not produce money for you, and whether fees depend on a recovery.

Who pays court costs and case expenses?

Confirm whether you may still be responsible for court costs and case expenses, even when fees are contingent.

Have questions about a fee agreement? Talk with our team first.

Related practice areas

Call Now — Free Consultation (404) 951-3513