Two cars parked at a roadside with an insurance claim form and clipboard resting on the hood.

Duluth, Georgia | Injury Guide for Metro Atlanta

How Do Insurance Companies Decide Who Is at Fault?

After a crash or injury, fault is often the central question. Here is a plain-language look at what insurers consider and how to get clear answers for your situation.

By Peter F. Jaraysi · Published November 2, 2026

Why the Fault Question Matters Right Now

How do insurance companies decide who is at fault? In short, they gather evidence, compare each driver’s account, and apply Georgia’s fault rules to the facts.

You may not have chosen this crash. Now an adjuster is calling, asking questions, and the decision feels urgent. That is a stressful place to be. It’s normal to feel unsure about what to say next.

The fault call matters early. It helps decide whether a claim is paid, reduced, or denied. It often shapes the first settlement offer, too. Small choices made early can affect how that view develops.

The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety reports that Georgia recorded 1,403 motor-vehicle crash deaths in 2024, a rate of 12.5 per 100,000 people. Those numbers show how common serious crashes are in the state.

This page explains the process in general terms. It does not predict how any particular claim will turn out. For broader context on injuries, claims, and options after a pedestrian crash, read the firm’s pedestrian accident information.

If an adjuster is deciding who was at fault in your crash, you don't have to sort it out alone. Our team can talk it through with you. Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.

Elderly couple meeting with a consultant across a desk, reviewing insurance paperwork together.

Georgia Is an At-Fault State

The person who caused the crash is generally responsible for the damages that crash caused.

The Georgia Office of the Commissioner of Insurance describes Georgia’s at-fault liability coverage. It also explains how that differs from a no-fault system. Liability coverage is the insurance that pays damages the at-fault driver causes, up to the policy limits.

Under O.C.G.A. § 51-1-2, ordinary negligence is the absence of ordinary diligence. Ordinary diligence is the care that ordinarily prudent people use in the same or similar circumstances.

In plain words, the question is this. Did someone fail to use reasonable care, and did that failure cause the harm? An adjuster asks the same question, and it drives the fault call.

The Police Report Is Often the Starting Point

The police crash report is usually the first document an adjuster reviews. It often sets the basic facts.

A typical report records the parties, the vehicles, and where each one was. It also lists witnesses, any citations, and the officer’s observations. Some reports include a diagram and notes about road conditions.

Adjusters use the report as a baseline. An officer’s notes are not automatically the final word on fault, though. The officer may not have seen the crash. The report may also rely on what drivers said at the scene.

Reports can contain errors or leave out details. If you spot a problem, write down exactly what is wrong. Keep a copy of your notes, and raise the issue with the insurer handling the claim.

A citation is one piece of evidence. It does not settle the civil fault question on its own. Insurers often weigh it along with everything else.

The Evidence Adjusters Actually Review

Knowing how insurance companies decide who is at fault starts with the evidence. Adjusters compare the physical evidence with each driver’s account. They look for the version that fits the facts.

Common evidence includes:

  • Photos and video of the vehicles, the scene, and the road
  • Damage patterns, such as where each vehicle was struck
  • Skid marks and debris locations
  • Traffic signals, signs, and lane markings
  • Weather and lighting conditions

Witness statements carry weight, especially from people with no connection to either driver. Adjusters weigh them against what each driver says. They look for gaps and contradictions.

Electronic data can matter too. Some vehicles record event data. Dash cameras and nearby business or traffic cameras may also capture a crash. Availability varies, and some footage is overwritten quickly, so early requests matter.

How Fault Percentages and Modified Comparative Negligence Work in Georgia

Georgia splits fault by percentage. An injured person’s own share of fault reduces what they can recover.

Under O.C.G.A. § 51-12-33, the judge reduces the damages in proportion to the injured person’s percentage of fault. The trier of fact, meaning the judge or jury deciding the facts, sets that percentage. The same statute says a plaintiff who is 50 percent or more responsible may not receive any damages.

Here is a simple illustration. Under the statute, if the plaintiff is to some degree responsible for the injury or damages claimed, the trier of fact determines the plaintiff’s percentage of fault, and the judge reduces the award in proportion to that percentage. If you were found 50 percent at fault, the statute would bar recovery.

The same statute also says each at-fault person pays only its own share. Those shares are not joint liability.

Insurers may argue for a higher percentage against you. Those arguments get tested with evidence, such as photos, witness accounts, and electronic data. Check the facts before accepting any percentage as settled.

Common Fault Scenarios: Rear-End Crashes, Turns, and Crosswalks

Fault in common crashes turns on who had the duty to act carefully. It also turns on whether that duty was met.

Rear-end crashes come up often in fault disputes. Adjusters look at following distance, braking, and any sudden stop. Fault in these cases depends on the facts of each crash.

Left turns, lane changes, and merges raise right-of-way questions. Adjusters look at who had the right of way and how the signals were timed. They also check whether a driver looked for other traffic before moving.

Crosswalks have specific rules in Georgia. Under O.C.G.A. § 40-6-91, a driver must stop and stay stopped to let a pedestrian cross within a crosswalk. That duty applies when the pedestrian is on the driver’s half of the road or approaching within one lane of it. The same section bars a pedestrian from suddenly leaving a curb into the path of a vehicle that is too close to stop.

Under O.C.G.A. § 40-6-92, a pedestrian crossing a roadway outside a marked crosswalk, or outside an unmarked crosswalk at an intersection, must yield to vehicles. That rule has an exception when the pedestrian has already entered the roadway safely. O.C.G.A. § 40-6-93 requires every driver to use due care to avoid colliding with a pedestrian.

Adjusters also examine visibility, lighting, and distraction. The same questions apply when the injured person is a passenger, a cyclist, or another driver.

Not sure what your next step is?

Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.

Why the Insurer’s Fault Decision Is Not Always the Final Word

An adjuster’s fault decision reflects the insurer’s position. It is not a court’s ruling.

If you disagree, you can ask the adjuster for the basis of the decision in writing. You can also send more evidence, such as a witness statement or a clearer photo. Then ask the insurer to reconsider.

Disputes that stay open may move to negotiation. If they still can’t be resolved, a lawsuit can be filed. In that case, the trier of fact decides fault under O.C.G.A. § 51-12-33.

Time matters. Under O.C.G.A. § 9-3-33, actions for injuries to the person generally must be brought within two years after the right of action accrues. Loss of consortium claims have four years. Don’t wait indefinitely while the insurer reviews the claim.

Common Mistakes That Can Shape the Fault Decision

Speculating about what happened can shape the file. So can admitting fault in an emotional moment. Even an honest guess made in shock can be used later. Stick to what you actually saw and heard.

A recorded statement is a formal record, not a casual chat. Before you give one, understand its purpose. Ask how the insurer plans to use it.

Signing releases or broad authorizations too early can close options. Read every document before you sign it. Be sure you know what your injuries are before you agree to anything.

Delaying medical care or missing follow-up appointments can complicate the injury record and the claim. Keep every appointment, and save every bill.

Keep a simple log. Note call dates, adjuster names, claim numbers, and documents you sent or received. When possible, send requests in writing so there is a record.

Should You Tell Your Own Insurance Company It Was Your Fault?

Be accurate and factual with your own insurer. Describe what you saw and did, and don’t guess at blame.

Separate facts from conclusions. Facts include the light color, your speed, where your car stopped, and what the other driver said at the scene. A conclusion is a statement like “it was my fault.” Stick to the facts.

Most auto policies ask you to report a crash and cooperate with the insurer’s investigation. Don’t hold back basic facts. Leaving out details can hurt you more than a clear, limited account.

If you’re unsure how a statement could be used, that uncertainty is a good reason to talk with our team before you give more detail.

Paramedics lift an injured person onto a stretcher on a city street.

Talk With Our Team About Your Crash

Right now, an adjuster may be deciding fault while you weigh your own account. The choices you make in the coming days can affect the claim.

Peter F. Jaraysi is the responsible lawyer for this page. The firm is based in Duluth, Georgia. It represents people injured in pedestrian, car, truck, motorcycle, and other accidents across Georgia.

You can request a free case review to talk through the crash, the insurer’s position, and your next steps. Your first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation to continue.

For more reading, see the firm’s Atlanta and Lawrenceville pedestrian accident pages and its older adult pedestrian questions page.

Who decides fault after a Georgia car accident?

The insurer makes its own fault call first. If the claim becomes a lawsuit, a judge or jury decides fault.

Does a police citation decide fault?

No. A citation is evidence, but it does not settle fault by itself. Insurers weigh it with other evidence.

How long do I have to file an injury lawsuit in Georgia?

Under O.C.G.A. § 9-3-33, actions for injuries to the person must generally be brought within two years after the right of action accrues, except that injuries to reputation must be brought within one year and loss of consortium actions within four years. Loss of consortium claims have four years.

Attorney advertising. The information on this page is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice; reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship with Slam Dunk Attorney. Peter F. Jaraysi is the lawyer responsible for this content. Slam Dunk Attorney, 2250 Satellite Blvd, Ste. 120, Duluth, GA 30097, 678-648-4238.

What to Expect When You Reach Out

Plain-Language Answers

We explain the process in everyday terms, so you know what questions matter for your claim.

Confidential Conversations

Your free first consultation is confidential, so you can share the details of what happened in a private setting.

No Obligation to Continue

Our free first consultation comes with no obligation to continue. You decide what comes next.

Serving Metro Atlanta and Georgia

Our team works with people across Atlanta, Gwinnett, Cobb, and North Fulton communities, from Lawrenceville and Johns Creek to Marietta and Dunwoody.

Speak With a Lawyer Before Giving a Statement

Insurance companies may ask for recorded statements or quick settlement agreements soon after an accident. Talking with a lawyer first can help you understand what you are being asked before you respond.

Accidents We Handle

Car and Truck Accidents

Collisions involving passenger vehicles, commercial trucks, and other large vehicles across Georgia.

Motorcycle and Pedestrian Accidents

Serious injuries to riders and people on foot, where fault and damages can be complex.

Rideshare and Short-Term Rental Injuries

Crashes involving Uber or Lyft, and injuries at Airbnb or VRBO properties.

Premises, Security, and Dog Bite Cases

Slip and fall injuries, negligent security incidents, and dog bite injuries.

Not Sure Who Is Responsible? Let's Talk.

Related practice areas

Call Now — Free Consultation (404) 951-3513